Café owner looking worried while reading a review on her phone

Bad, unfair or fake Google reviews: what you can remove and how to reply

By Terence Walsh | TWDA Design | Northumberland web design
Reading time: ~7 minutes | Category: Business Tips

Introduction

Everyone who runs a pub, hotel or holiday let gets one eventually. A one-star review from someone who says the food was cold, when you know it wasn’t. Someone complaining about the price of a room they booked at that price. Or a review from a name you’ve never seen, about a visit that never happened.

It stings, especially when you’ve put everything into the place. The good news is that one bad review does far less damage than people fear, and how you respond matters more than the review itself.

This post covers what Google will actually remove, how to report the reviews that break the rules, and how to reply to the ones that don’t.

“Every owner I’ve ever talked to remembers their worst review word for word. Very few of their customers do. People read the reply. A calm, polite response to an unfair review often does more for you than another five-star one.”

— Terence Walsh, TWDA Creative Services

First, take a breath

Don’t reply straight away. Don’t reply after a long shift, and definitely not after a glass of wine. Make a cup of tea, have a Jaffa Cake, and come back to it tomorrow. Replies written in anger stay online long after you’ve calmed down.

What Google will remove

Google only removes reviews that break its policies. It’s quite clear that it won’t remove a review just because you disagree with it or because it’s negative.

Reviews that can be removed include:

  • Fake or spam reviews: from someone who was never a customer, or multiple reviews posted by one person
  • Conflicts of interest: from a competitor, a former employee or someone with a grudge from outside the business
  • Off-topic reviews: about politics, a news story or something that isn’t about the customer’s experience
  • Offensive content: hate speech, harassment, profanity or sexual content
  • Personal information: a staff member’s phone number or home address, for example
  • Reviews offered in exchange for something, including someone threatening a bad review unless you give them a refund

A review from a real guest saying they didn’t enjoy their stay, however unfair it feels, isn’t going anywhere.

How to report a review

From your profile

  1. Go to your Business Profile and select Read reviews.
  2. Find the review and click the Report (flag) option next to it.
  3. Choose the reason that fits best.
  4. Send the report.

Using the Reviews Management Tool

Google also has a Reviews Management Tool where you can report reviews and check the status of anything you’ve already reported. Google says it usually takes several days to assess a report. If it decides not to remove the review, you can appeal once through the same tool, and you’ll get an email with the final decision.

Report each problem review separately, choose the most accurate reason, and don’t report the same one over and over. It won’t speed anything up.

What about a sudden flood of bad reviews?

Sometimes a business gets lots of one-star reviews in a day or two, often after a social media row or a local news story that has nothing to do with the customer experience. That’s exactly what Google’s off-topic and fake engagement rules are for. Report each review, and keep screenshots with dates in case you need to appeal.

Should you pay someone to remove reviews?

No. Companies promising to “remove bad reviews” can’t do anything you can’t do yourself with the report button. Some use methods that break Google’s rules or the law. Under UK law since April 2025, businesses can’t present reviews in a misleading way or have genuine negative reviews suppressed. It isn’t worth the risk. (There’s more on the fake reviews ban in our AI and the new rules guide.)

Pub landlord behind the bar checking the till screen

How to reply to a bad review

Your reply isn’t really for the reviewer. It’s for the hundred people who’ll read it before they book. Keep that in mind and it gets much easier.

The simple version

  1. Thank them for taking the time, even if it hurts.
  2. Acknowledge the problem without arguing. “I’m sorry the room wasn’t as warm as you’d hoped” is fine, even if you think it was perfectly warm.
  3. Explain briefly if there’s something useful to say, like “our kitchen closes at 8.30pm on Sundays”, without making excuses.
  4. Say what you’ve done or what you’ll do.
  5. Offer to talk offline with an email address or phone number.
  6. Keep it short. Four or five sentences is plenty.

What not to do

  • Don’t argue point by point.
  • Don’t share anything about the guest’s booking, what they said at the time or who they were with. It’s their personal data, and it looks awful.
  • Don’t accuse them of lying in public, even if you think they are. If you believe a review is fake, report it, then reply briefly: “We can’t find a booking under this name. Please get in touch so we can look into it.”
  • Don’t copy and paste the same apology under every review.

An example

Review: “Waited 45 minutes for food on Sunday. Staff didn’t seem to care. Won’t be back.”

Reply: “Thanks for letting us know, and I’m sorry. A 45-minute wait isn’t what we want for anyone. Sunday lunch was busier than we’d planned for, and we’ve since changed how we take bookings so the kitchen isn’t swamped at 1pm. I’d really like to hear more, so please email me at [email] if you’re willing. — [Name], owner”

That reply doesn’t grovel and doesn’t argue. Anyone reading it thinks, “They sound reasonable.”

You can edit or delete your reply later from the same Read reviews screen. Google moderates replies before they appear, which usually takes a few minutes. The reviewer gets a notification, and people do sometimes update their review after a decent reply.

“The best outcome with a bad review isn’t getting it removed. It’s the reviewer changing it to four stars because you replied like a human being. It happens more often than you’d think.”

— Terence Walsh

Drown it out, honestly

The best protection against one bad review is lots of genuine good ones. A single one-star among 150 reviews barely moves your average. Among eight, it’s a disaster. If you haven’t already, read our guide to getting more Google reviews the right way and start asking every customer.

A quick checklist

  1. Don’t reply in the heat of the moment.
  2. Does it break Google’s rules? If so, report it.
  3. Check its status in the Reviews Management Tool, and appeal once if needed.
  4. Reply calmly, briefly and without personal details.
  5. Offer to take it offline.
  6. Keep asking every customer for reviews.

Bad and fake reviews

Dealing with unfair reviews?

If you’re dealing with a run of unfair reviews, or want help replying and setting up a better way to collect good ones, get in touch. It’s part of our local SEO work for Northumberland businesses.

Bad and fake reviews

Perhaps we can help with your design project?